blogs
Signs Your ATS Isn’t Helping with Screening: Spotting Efficiency Gaps in Automation

Ruchi |MyNextHire | January 1, 2025

Today’s fast-paced recruiting arena necessitates functional Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) for quickly identifying appropriate talent. Nevertheless, many heads of TA and senior recruiters are unhappy with their current ATS, which they think hinders the recruitment process instead of enhancing it. By and large, these frustrations reveal inefficiencies in the system that require correction. This article attempts to identify and delineate normal ATS problems, address your pain points, and assist you in getting better solutions.

Signs of an Incompetent ATS

All you need is to know the signs of a failing ATS and they will be easily detectable. Some of the subtle symptoms indicating recruitment difficulties might include;

  • Delayed resume screening software processes : Whenever candidate shortlisting through your ATS takes more time than anticipated, consider it to lack sufficient parameters that can accommodate numerous applications adequately.
  • Consistent inability by the ATS to sort resumes accurately : Could it be that your system fails in identifying top talent among the resumes submitted? This means that whenever such an ATS resume screeningdevice is malfunctioning, then members will always have to revisit every application manually thereby wasting time.
  • Variability in outcomes produced by resume screen software:For example, if you have qualified individuals who still don’t make it into the interview list because their CVs were ignored during the shortlisting process through automatic reply systems (ATS) this signifies the poor performance of your ATS-automated filtering mechanism.

When these are combined, they take longer to hire employees, increasing overall costs, and delivering a bad experience for candidates.

Main Symptoms of ATS Problems

These are certain ATS problems that could be impeding your recruitment efforts:


1. Limited customizability options

Many ATS prevent tailoring so that recruitment needs are always unique leaving teams no choice but manual labour activities.

2. Repetitive tasking automation in mediocrity

The goal of features like automatic ATS screening of resumes is to simplify rather than complicate work processes. If elementary activities such as sorting out job applications cannot be handled through process automation, it is time for a rethink.

3. Inability to integrate with other systems development programs

Integration with your HRMS, job boards, or collaboration tools is a must-have feature in any modern ATS. In other words, without integration capacities, switching platforms by your team is a waste of time and effort, imposing a possibility of mistakes.

Classic ATS screening tests often fail when one deals with niche roles or candidates having one-page resumes because they can’t be adjusted to the point of making correct choices.

Why These Problems Still Persist

Most ATS challenges arise from archaic models that were built just for basic tracking purposes rather than informed decision-making. Building state-of-the-art software requires employing advanced technologies, while legacy systems frequently fail to leverage intelligence.

Furthermore, numerous recruiters usually express dissatisfaction due to an awful user experience with legacy systems. As user-friendliness declines, so do adoption rates among team members as well as bottlenecks arising.

Detecting ATS Efficiency Gaps

Answer these questions to determine if your ATS meets expectations

  • Is there too much time spent screening resumes manually by members of staff who are engaged in recruitment activities?
  • Does this system generate accurate and actionable results based on tests conducted after every stage of screening an application for employment?
  • Whether it affects candidate experience during the interviewing stages or even delays time before these individuals can be hired into different roles within an organization.

If you answered ‘Yes’ at least once in any question listed above then probably instead of solving inefficiencies, it is causing some of them.

A Smarter Solution — MyNextHire

This is where MyNextHire comes into play — which was designed mainly to cater to those TA heads who are looking forward to revolutionizing recruitment by eliminating inefficiencies associated with traditional ATS platforms.

Unlike outdated systems that lack automation or have poor user interface design (UI), MyNextHire integrates advanced resume-screening software & automation tools easily so as not to make recruiters lose focus when trying to find the best talents possible rather than spending unnecessary time on screening every applicants’ resume personally.

Using Artificial Intelligence (AI), ensures faster yet accurate ATS screening resumes, helping companies hire better talent faster.

Key Features of MyNextHire:
  • AI-powered application parsing - Boosts efficacy rate for an ATS in analyzing different job seeker applications that were submitted online
  • Seamless integrations –HRMS connections without any data transfer breakage during the hiring process
  • Intuitive user interface (UI) –this tool is more dependent on UI than other aspects like customer service delivery

Through MyNextHire, inefficiencies such as slow ATS screening tests and frequent ATS problems become a thing of the past.

The Bottom Line

Having an ineffective ATS can lead to both, loss of time and money for the organization as well as frustration among the recruitment team. So, spotting efficiency gaps like delays with ATS resume screening or frequent ATS issues early can save you from compound recruitment problems in the future.

MyNextHire provides an answer to the demands of contemporary recruiters. The AI-first approach simplifies resume screening software, automates redundancies, and integrates well with current tools to give you actual results.

Do you want to change how you hire? To know more about improving the recruitment process using MyNextHire request a demo and see it in action right now

Increase Your Hiring Efficiency by 30% in 4 weeks!

Want to talk to One of the MyNextHire SMEs to find out how?
Schedule a Free Demo